NetWorth Services Assists the IRS in Determining Tax Gap from Schedule
D
Working
with IRS
National Taxpayer Advocate Service - FY 2002 Annual Report To
Congress
Washington, D.C. - Jan. 2003 - The IRS is currently exploring the use of
publicly available software that will help determine the cost basis for
securities transactions. Such technology can reduce taxpayer burden by
streamlining documentation of cost basis calculations during audits and can
create a reliable standard for taxpayers, preparer, and the IRS.
The National Taxpayer Advocate encourages the IRS to continue it efforts to
reduce taxpayer burden regarding capital gain and loss issues, and supports all
education and assistance efforts that are currently in place. Our office is
particularly interested in the computer software that the IRS is testing
regarding the computation of basis. It appears this initiative would not only
significantly reduce taxpayer burden in preparing tax returns, but would also
impact the number of audits, administrative appeals, and litigated cases that
result in a disagreement between taxpayers and the IRS regard.
Top
Investing After Selling Losers, Investors Also Must Face
Tax Nightmare
By LYNN ASINOF
Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
September 26, 2002 - As he watched the stock market plummet in mid-July,
Jack Collins lost heart. On the day the stock market hit a four-year low, the
retired Pfafftown, N.C., investor sold Lucent and AT&T Wireless shares spun
off from the AT&T stock that he'd purchased years ago.
But he and other long-term investors who took part in this year's sell-off have
to deal with more than seller's remorse. They've created a giant tax headache.
To protect their savings, many people dumped investments -- or spin offs from
investments -- that they bought and then held for decades. In some cases, there
are huge gains, but many have no idea what they paid for the stock they've
sold. In order to calculate their taxes, they must now unravel the convoluted
history of the stocks, many of which have had mergers, stock splits and spin
offs over the years.
These corporate changes -- which generated huge stock movements throughout the
'90s -- have made it incredibly complicated to figure out what a share of stock
was originally worth. Folks who bought Manufacturers Hanover stock in the 1980s
now -- after three mergers and two stock splits -- own shares of J.P. Morgan
Chase. Those who bought Time Inc. two decades ago have seen their shares become
Time Warner and most recently AOL Time Warner.
And consider this: Someone who bought American can stock back in the 1970s would
end up today with shares of both Citigroup and the insurance company Travelers
Property Casualty. If he or she sells the Travelers, a portion of the original
American Can investment is treated as the purchase price of those shares. But
how much? Among other things, it depends on the fair market value of the stocks
on the day of spin-off.
"It will be ugly," says Norman P. Posner, an accountant with Samet & Co.,
Chestnut Hill, Mass., who is already girding for an onslaught of clients who
need to reconstruct these records before filing their 2002 tax returns. People
selling stock held more than a year must pay capital-gains taxes, typically
20%, on any profit over the original purchase price
No one knows exactly how many investors are affected. But John Markese,
president of the American Association of Individual Investors in Chicago, says
a huge wave of long-term investors sold into the nose-diving market. "I got far
more calls in late July than I ever did in any other market downturn, including
1987," he says.
The 3.7 million AT&T shareowners are the poster children for the tax-basis
problem. In addition to adjusting for stock splits over the years, they also
must deal with a litany of stock spin-offs and mergers that could leave a
shareholder tracing as many as 19 different companies if they bought before the
1983 breakup.
"Please, please, on bended knee, don't even think of selling," AT&T
shareholder Frances Corneaby of Robbinsdale, Minn., says her accountant told
her. She knows she first bought shares of the old AT&T for about $300 in
1955, but can't find the records. Now her investment has grown into a
multi-stock portfolio valued in the mid-six figures. "I think it totally
unreasonable of the IRS to expect us to have records 47 years old," she says.
To make things worse, the IRS has a new compliance weapon that could make this
year's calculations particularly painful. In the past, investors who couldn't
come up with a cost have often guessed, and the IRS probably couldn't figure it
out any better. Now new software promises to help the IRS track trades back as
far as 1962, making it much easier for them to spot mistakes. The software will
debut as part of the IRS's National Research Project, a spot-audit of 50,000
random taxpayers scheduled to launch this fall.
According to IRS rules, those who can't come up with a proper cost basis have to
calculate capital-gains tax as if the investment cost is zero and pay taxes on
the entire proceeds of the sale.
People who don't want to do that should start by contacting the company itself,
since it may have detailed shareholder records. AT&T, for example, says its
stock-transfer agent EquiServe can track information back to 1984 through a
Social Security number or certificate number.
For those who want to do the work themselves, the AT&T Web site at
http://www.att.com/ offers a detailed breakdown of corporate changes, complete
with worksheets. A workbook titled "AT&T Tax Wizard," currently available
in paper form, provides an off-line tutorial for doing the calculations.
Shareholders can get more information on the workbook at
http://www.atttaxwizard.com/.
There are resources for shareholders of other companies as well. Glen Feeney of
Maryland Heights, Mo., owns 216 shares of Emerson Electric as a result of an
employee stock-plan purchase in January 1970, but no longer has the records.
For the past three months, he has been trying to reconstruct his stock purchase
and the history of company stock splits.
By using tools available on market-data Web sites, such as the Java charts at
the brand-new http://www.prophet.net/, or the historical data at
http://www.bigcharts.com/, it was relatively simple to find a split-adjusted
Emerson stock price of $4.91 on Jan. 13, 1970.
In cases where there is no online information, people can revert to the public
library, getting stock prices from old newspapers and then checking out stock
splits and other changes in the CCH Capital Changes Reporter, which tracks all
corporate changes back over 100 years.
That's where Stanley Stein of Lauderdale Lakes, Fla., may end up as he tries to
reconstruct the basis of his mother-in-law's portfolio inherited from her
husband in 1966. Mr. Stein has to tap her portfolio to pay for her care, so he
sold 100 shares of AT&T in July. But there's no supporting paperwork to
establish basis. "She threw everything out," he says.
There are, however, a couple of ways to get rid of stock without any such
headaches. People who give appreciated stock to charity can get a tax deduction
for the full market value of the stock.
Or they can take Mrs. Corneaby's approach. Stocks get a new tax basis pegged to
the date of death when the owner dies, and she plans to keep holding it. "Let
my heirs figure it out," she says.
Write to Lynn Asinof at lynn.asinof@wsj.com
Top
Prying Eyes IRS tests software that will track capital gains
By JIM MCTAGUE
BARRON'S Online
Monday, August 19, 2002 - If you have sold a stock or a bond and have
claimed a loss on your tax returns when you actually had a gain or fudged the
numbers in other ways to reduce your capital-gains tax, then you may soon have
reason to chew on your nails. The Internal Revenue Service is testing new
software that might be able detect your cheating ways. If the software passes
muster, the IRS will use it as part of the new National Research Project, an
annual spot-audit of 50,000 random taxpayers.
The software was developed by a fledgling, privately held company in Tucson
called NetWorth Services. The company has a 10-gigabyte database containing
every single trade price for stocks and bonds traded in three major markets for
the last 20 years. NetWorth believes that it can help the IRS determine the
cost basis for every share you sell, even if you have been reinvesting the
dividends for years and years and have lost your original paperwork.
"This is not a policing tool," NetWorth spokeswoman Marisa Diaz emphasized.
"It's not designed to help the IRS clamp down on people." Her spin is that the
new software is a "positive tool" in that it will enable the IRS quickly to
eliminate accurate returns from its auditing sample, which makes it sound more
like a cotton gin than a high-tech bloodhound. "It would be a teeny-weeny part
of the National Research Project," she said. The software tests go on at least
through October.
The National Research Program is still scheduled to launch sometime in the fall.
The last time the IRS conducted spot audits on this scale was in 1988.
Line-by-line dissections of the returns of 55,000 randomly selected taxpayers
indicated that 8% of the populace was underreporting taxes to the tune of $200
billion a year. The random audits were so expensive, time-consuming, and
excruciating for both crooked and honest taxpayers that Congress demanded the
IRS put a stop to them and come up with a kinder and gentler method for
gathering the data.
Under the new program, 50,000 returns will be selected from several sample
groups, such as self-employed people, wealthy taxpayers, and corporations; but
not every one of those taxpayers will be subjected to a face-to-face,
line-by-line scrutiny. IRS Commissioner Charles Rossotti previously estimated
that 8,000 of the randomly selected returns would pass the smell test,
requiring no action. Some 9,000 taxpayers might receive a letter requesting
information about specific line items. A block of 30,000 taxpayers will have to
visit an IRS office for a "limited scope audit," which means they will not
require documentation for every line of their return. Finally, about 2,000 will
have to sit through a line-by-line audit with "reasonable substantiation
expected." This means that if they lack documentation for a specific line item
but have a convincing story, they might avoid a penalty for under-reporting
their taxes.
Pen Pals
The five pens provided for President Bush at the signing of the Corporate
Responsibility Act are certainly hot collector items. But beware if you ever
encounter one on the secondary market. Bush only used three of the pens when he
signed the bill on July 30, despite press accounts to the contrary. We were
there and we later reviewed the video tapes to double-check our observation.
Bush mixed the pens in his right fist with the deftness of a three-card Monte
dealer before he handed them out. From our vantage point, it appeared that Bush
handed a "real" pen to Republican Rep. Michael Oxley, one of the Bill's two
sponsors. Maryland Democrat Sen. Paul Sarbanes, the other co-sponsor, initially
appeared to us to have gotten one of the unused pens. But reviews of the
videotape provided inconclusive evidence. The president also presented pens to
Sen. Majority Leader Tom Daschle of South Dakota and Sen. Minority Leader Trent
Lott of Mississippi. He kept one pen for his presidential library.
Harry Rubenstein, a curator of political history at the Smithsonian Institution,
says the pens used by Bush might be more valuable to collectors if, indeed,
they can be identified. If not, they'd all be worth about the same. Rubenstein
adds that he doesn't know when the tradition of giving away pens began. He
believes it originated in the 18th century at treaty signings.
Chicago lawyer and pen collector John Loring says that Roosevelt, Truman and
Eisenhower used inexpensive wood-shaft dip pens to sign bills. During Ike's
last year, he substituted an Esterbrook pen that looked like a dip pen but held
ink like a fountain pen, says Loring. Bush uses cross medium-point, felt-tipped
pens for bill signings, according to the White House.
Bill Clinton, not surprisingly, was a prolific dispenser of souvenir signing
pens. He used 20 Parker pens at one ceremony and 16 at another. Bush, by
comparison, is a pen-miser. When he signed the trade legislation recently, he
used just two pens.
Top
IRS Contract to Provide Information Technology Support
Tucson, Arizona - August 10, 2002 - NetWorth Services, Inc., today
announced that it was awarded an IRS contract to provide its net basis/equity
basis determination application, NetBasis 2000 (NB2), to the National Research
Program (NRP). Using a batch system process, NB2 will retrieve the historical
price and corporate activity data, and then determine the cost basis of major
stocks.
NetBasis 2000 (NB2) a patent pending software system developed by NWS,
successfully retrieves an accurate adjusted cost basis of any investment
regardless of its history of capital changes. These changes include stock
splits, spin-offs, mergers, special dividends, dividend reinvestment programs
and return of capital.
NetWorth Services is very proud to be a part of the modernization efforts that
are taking place at the IRS. NB2 will provide an advancement technological
method by using verification to minimize taxpayer burden.
Top
NRP - NetWorth Services, Inc.
Phoenix, AZ - Sept 20, 2001 - NetWorth Services, Inc. was awarded a
purchase order on a sole source basis from The Internal Revenue Service for
information technology support for contractor programming, for a net
basis/equity basis determination application to test the viability, accuracy
and cost/benefits of using such a system to support the National Research
Program (NRP). This application would provide data on the cost basis and
history of major stocks to assist with calculations of stock equity.
Top
NetWorth Services Assists the IRS in Determining Tax Gap from
Schedule D
Phoenix, Arizona - April 4, 2005 - The Internal Revenue Service has
released preliminary results from the 2001 National Research Program's (NRP)
random audit of 46,000 tax payers, in which NetBasis (Nb2) was used as a
verification tool for cost basis information. With the ability to accurately
verify reported capital gains and losses on the Schedule D, the IRS identified
an unreported capital gains tax gap of $6 billion to $9 billion per year and
$50 billion or so in non-business income such as dividends and capital gains
that people fail to report. The tax gap is the difference between what
taxpayers should pay and what they actually pay on a timely basis.
"The results of the Tax Gap Report definitely exceeded our conservative
estimates of lost revenue attributed to erroneous or unreported capital gains,
said Nico R. Willis, CEO of NetWorth Services. "This report illustrates that
the problem is greater than we originally anticipated. We are pleased to be
able to provide the IRS with a solution to this problem."
IRS Commissioner Mark W. Everson announced that an additional analysis of the
tax gap should be completed by the year-end, which may present a tax gap that
further falls outside of the reported range. The next stage of the NRP is to
finish the data analysis, refine the tax gap data and use that data to update
the statistical tools used to select individual returns for audit, an important
step in strengthening compliance with the tax system.
Nb2 is a simple, internet-based system that accomplishes in minutes what
formerly seemed impossible. With as little information as the year of purchase,
Nb2 quickly and easily filters through its massive database of financial
information and within seconds, reaches back into time and recreates a complete
history of that investment and then delivers the accurate adjusted cost basis.
Nb2 is the only product on the market that reconstructs the historical cost
basis, and provides the security pricing. Furthermore, with the IRS and
accounting firms both using the Nb2 system, NetWorth Services is rapidly moving
towards creating an industry standard. When we designed this system, our goal
was to level the playing field between the tax payer and the government,"
continued Nico Willis. "A system, such as Nb2, contributes to building a level
of trust between tax return reporting and review through an impartial system
where both parties arrive at the same numbers; giving a virtual stamp of
approval to any data submitted."
Top |